Reviewing fic
May. 26th, 2006 12:18 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
sg_lab2While reading fanfic on a site that shows reviews, I was thinking, "I can't review this." I look at all the reviews and they're just gushing with praise. While there's nothing wrong with praise, I like to balance that out with some constructive criticism. One I read I thought was a very good story, but that there were just some things that would make it better. I was afraid my comments would be received as a downer from other reviewers.
I read one review for a fic who felt the need to qualify their remarks to assure the author they weren't bashing the writting. As far as I was concerned I thought it was a well thought out polite review. Not a single flame to be seen.
Personally, if I write something, I want constructive remarks. If you don't agree with my characterization of a character steer me in the right direction. If I'm switching tenses PLEASE tell me. I hate switching tenses. Uhh, anyway. Polite constructive criticism is always welcome when I write something.
I read one review for a fic who felt the need to qualify their remarks to assure the author they weren't bashing the writting. As far as I was concerned I thought it was a well thought out polite review. Not a single flame to be seen.
Personally, if I write something, I want constructive remarks. If you don't agree with my characterization of a character steer me in the right direction. If I'm switching tenses PLEASE tell me. I hate switching tenses. Uhh, anyway. Polite constructive criticism is always welcome when I write something.
